Question 1

What's the difference between rcl and rclcpp?

Accepted Answer

rcl is a C library that provides the foundation for implementing ROS 2 client libraries, while rclcpp is the C++ client library built on top of rcl. Use rcl if you're developing a new language binding; use rclcpp for writing C++ ROS 2 nodes directly without dealing with low-level C code.

Question 2

How do I create a custom ROS 2 client library using rcl?

Accepted Answer

Start by including rcl in your build system, implement language bindings by calling rcl's C API for core concepts like nodes and topics, and integrate with the ROS 2 middleware layer. Study existing implementations like rclpy (Python) or rcljava for best practices and to avoid common pitfalls.

Question 3

Does rcl support real-time operations in robotics?

Accepted Answer

rcl is designed to be efficient and can be used in real-time systems, but support depends on the underlying RMW implementation and proper configuration. For hard real-time requirements, ensure your RMW layer (e.g., Fast RTPS) is configured appropriately and test thoroughly in your target environment.

Question 4

Can I use rcl without the full ROS 2 stack?

Accepted Answer

No, rcl is tightly coupled with ROS 2 and its middleware abstractions. It requires a compatible RMW implementation and ROS 2 infrastructure, making it unsuitable for standalone use outside the ROS 2 ecosystem or for projects that mix frameworks.

Question 5

How to parse YAML configuration files with rcl?

Accepted Answer

Use the rcl_yaml_param_parser package included in rcl, which provides functions to read and parse YAML files for node parameters. This allows dynamic configuration in your client library, but you'll need to handle C-level memory management and error checking manually.

Question 6

Is rcl thread-safe for concurrent node operations?

Accepted Answer

rcl provides basic thread safety for core operations, but developers must manage concurrency carefully when implementing language bindings. The API allows safe access from multiple threads, but specific usage patterns and synchronization should be tested to avoid race conditions in your implementation.

rcl

What is rcl?

Overview

Use Cases

Best For

Found a gem we're missing?

Not Ideal For

Pros & Cons

Pros

Cons

Frequently Asked Questions