Question 1

How to set up Elmish with React in F#?

Accepted Answer

Install the Fable.Elmish NuGet package in your F# project, configure Fable to compile F# to JavaScript, then define model, update, and view functions. The view function should return React elements, and the app is mounted using Elmish's React bindings—check the docs site for detailed examples.

Question 2

Elmish vs Redux for F# projects?

Accepted Answer

Elmish is generally better for F# projects as it's designed to be idiomatic to F# and natively follows the Elm architecture, whereas Redux is JavaScript-centric. Elmish offers a more seamless functional approach, making state management more predictable and integrated within F# codebases.

Question 3

Can Elmish be used with Blazor?

Accepted Answer

Elmish is primarily targeted at JavaScript renderers like React, and the README doesn't mention Blazor support. While theoretically possible with a custom renderer, it's not officially supported, so integration would require significant additional effort and experimentation.

Question 4

Is Elmish good for large-scale applications?

Accepted Answer

Yes, Elmish is suitable for large-scale applications due to its predictable Elm architecture, which enforces clear state management and separation of concerns. However, the niche F# ecosystem might mean fewer pre-built solutions or community plugins for complex needs.

Question 5

How does Elmish handle asynchronous operations?

Accepted Answer

Elmish handles asynchronous operations through commands (Cmd) in the update function, similar to Elm. This allows side effects like API calls to be managed in a controlled, functional way, with results dispatched back to the update cycle for state changes.

Question 6

What are the main differences between Elmish and Elm?

Accepted Answer

Elmish is a library for F# that implements Elm's architecture, while Elm is a standalone functional language. Elmish lets you stay in the .NET ecosystem with F#, integrating with existing tools, whereas Elm requires learning a new language and toolchain, though both share the model-view-update pattern.

Elmish

What is Elmish?

Overview

Use Cases

Best For

Related Projects

Found a gem we're missing?

Not Ideal For

Pros & Cons

Pros

Cons

Open Source Alternative To

Frequently Asked Questions